New York Butcher Shoppe is all about the meat. The high-end specialty grocery store offers a variety of fresh-cut aged Certified Angus USDA Prime and Choice steaks and roasts as well as premium high-quality pork, lamb, chicken, and veal as well as homemade sausages alongside an extensive selection of fine wines and craft beers along with gourmet pastas, imported grocery items and cheeses.
The menu includes a selection of popular sandwiches, as well as the option the build-your-own sandwich. Diners select their choice of bread, toppings and choose hot or cold on an iPad while placing their order, making for the perfect sandwich, every time.
We tried the Brooklyn and the Verrazanno for our first visit. We couldn’t believe how large the sandwiches were, with almost a pound of meat on each one. Chips were served alongside and included in the price of only $9.99.
The Verrazanno was packed with pastrami, corned beef, cheese, and (in my case) topped with spicy mustard. The thinly-sliced, almost shredded meat fell apart in mouth. Absolutely delicious.
The Brooklyn piled sky-high with Boar’s Head salami, prosciutto, capicola, and provolone.
We didn’t even eat half of our sandwiches, but we couldn’t leave without a touch of something sweet, so we went for their house-made brownies. These perfectly-baked, crumbly on the outside and chewy on the inside brownies put the final touch on a fantastic lunch.
YELP users agree that New York Butcher Shoppe is the local go-to for sandwich fixes:
“Wow….simply wow! This place knows how to make a sandwich”
-Rob S. on YELP
“I am giving this rating on the sandwich alone. If you go and get one, I hope you are hungry. They are HUGE! They obviously use quality, fresh ingredients. I have had a few different types and have never been disappointed.”
-Will B. on YELP
New York Butcher Shoppe is located at:
3158 Heights Vlg
Vestavia Hills, Alabama
Business Hours are Monday-Saturday 10AM-7PM